Why? Where does he actually criticize Why I am not a Muslim? silly and has been debunked 1843903904 times, I wanted to like this book. Ibn Warraq - Why I Am Not a Muslim. The books starts a bit heavy and full of facts and comparisons between Islam and Christianity and Judaism but its only when it delves into interpretations of specific passages of the Koran and the devious methods of the Prophet that it becomes more readable and interesting. It took me a week and a half to read it, and it felt like the longest week and a half of my life. "Why I am Not a Muslim" is probably one of the highlights of religion criticism. Please do read these articles in order. The chapter on Women in Islam alone should make you cringe. I read two great books by Nabeel Qureshi, also a Muslim that fell away from his faith but fell into Christianity. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. However, as pointed out, the claim to truth here, ie, that a theist confirms the author's argument is flawed and therefore disingenuous at best, completely devoid of intellectual honesty at worse. The author claims that Luther denied the virgin birth and then strengthens his position on this by stating that Christian Biblical Scholars agree with the argument. Its relevance today cannot be ignored and some sections are disturbing indeed (namely the real implication of jihad and how an Islamic state views itself and the other part of the world). Compared to Qureshi, there is poor research with many sources. Please wait while we load book reader. In my opinion, Warraq makes a good argument that many non-controversially Islamic ideas are (at the very least) incompatible with many modern ideas about politics, morality, and epistemology. Why I Am Not a Muslim does have a mocking quality, to be sure, but it is a serious and thought-provoking book. Feuerbach has a possible excuse in that in the 1800's it would not be as easy to research a claimed reference as it is now. Islam is not a religion like Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link. It took me a week and a half to read it, and it felt like the longest week and a half of my life. It's difficult to live up to Russell, but Ibn Warraq makes a good go of it. For me, hell does not make sense. Why I Am Not A Muslim (Ibn Warraq) Item Preview. Comprehensive. Ibn Warraq - Why I Am Not a Muslim. The book, a critical look at the origins and theology of Islam, has been well-received and widely read around the world, and now enters its second edition, including a newly-written Foreward by Ayaan Hirsi Ali. I am truly proud to be a Muslim because I know Islam is the right religion and I am on the right path. "Why I Am Not a Muslim" is knowledgeable, wide-ranging and well researched although a trifle protracted in places. Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer. I learned a lot about Islam and Muhammed and certainly gained a new perspective on the religion and it's relationship to world history and politics. I guess the the main reason for reading works by Ibn Warraq is best summarized by the following statement by E.Renan. So, I wanted another perspective, someone who fell away but into atheism. Kent Hovind - Why I Am Not A Muslim (November-11-2020) Published in Kent Hovind. So I am here to give you a honest view of why I do not believe in Islam. those who would learn why Islam is neither loving nor peaceful to non-Muslims nor Muslims. Yet, it isn't an *infinitely* elastic subject: it must, in principle, be possible to delineate a set of specifically Islamic doctrines, beliefs and practices, if we are to have any hope of speaking of it at all. 32 Full PDFs related to this paper. They are extremely guarded about their religion, and what they consider blasphemous acts by skeptical Muslims and non-Muslims alike has only served to pique the world's curiosity. Buy Why I Am Not a Muslim New Ed by Ibn Warraq (ISBN: 9781591020110) from Amazon's Book Store. One major factor: the punishment for apostasy - i.e. I like this book because the author presents his case in a logical and informative way. The reference that Ibn Warraq uses is to a German philosopher, Feuerbach, who lived some 300 years after Luther. It is very analytical and larded with secondary literature, but the author achieves his goal: to fully dissect Islam (and some bits of Christianity and Judaism). Ibn Warraq is the pseudonym used by this author of two controversial books, Why I Am not a Muslim and The Quest for the Historical Muhammad. Sadly enough however todays events show him to be correct. Most of my values are based on the spiritual aspects of the Muslim faith. Its relevance today cannot be ignored and some sections are disturbing indeed (namely the real implication of jihad and how an Islamic state views itself and the other part of the world). I wanted to like this book. Then you just go to Borders or Barnes and Nobles and get this book and digest it as well as the other works of Ibn Warraq. There is a certain logicbehind it which will otherwise get lost. "Muslim and proud " And someone said :"the video is sad but the comments are sadder" The replies : "well then cry it off" "why don't you go and cry about it then" Someone i used to follow said : "If God made you gay he would've sent you straight to hell m8, just don't be sinner" "Islam … An eyeopener. and why we must stop Islam now before Islam stops us later. It simply is not the case in. You can download the paper by clicking the button above. It's difficult to live up to Russell, but Ibn Warraq makes a good go of it. Although I only fasted for three days, the experience has stayed with me, so that even now, weeks later, I am still reflecting on that time. Why? Yet, it isn't an *infinitely* elastic subject: i. Ultimately, Warraq's arguments against belief in Islam and for the strict separation of church and state are quite convincing. Although this book is an enlightening read on some of the more unsavoury aspects of Islamic culture, I have to say I'm not a fan of the author's writing style. Warraq explains the history of Islam and the true nature of the religion. Ibn Warraq arranges his abundant materials on no obvious principles. Regardless, the material was very edifying and I found the latter chapters on Al-Ma'arri and Women in Islam riveting. If you are pressured in marriage into converting to Islam, by all means get a copy of this book and read it very well. Although chapters 10 & 11 appear somewhat tedious, others (like on Ar. His writing has a dry textbook-like quality to it that completely lacks any life or humour. The Extreme Sign Got Them in the Pews! Pastor Donald Fareed, Founder of Persian Ministries International (PMI) being interviewed by San Francisco … By using our site, you agree to our collection of information through the use of cookies. a compelling book for all Muslim-born and Muslim skeptics. . As author himself admits, this book is composed mainly of excerpts from various sources, with the author taking the role of their presenter while discussing different subjects concerning Islam. It is easy to build an argument in one's favour by choosing references that strengthen your position, in this case, in the guise of an apparent reference from a theist (ie Luther). Good book, it refers to the letter of Bertrand Russell "why I am not a Christian" I do think that Ibn Warraq on occasion goes a bit overboard. This now makes me question all the references this author has used. Luther himself was well aware of this claim upon himself but Luther responded outright, calling it a lie, that he never said this. He begins with a chapter entitled 'The Rushdie Affair', which deals mainly with the maltreatment of dissidents within the Islamic world and the failure of so many Western Islamicists to adopt a properly critical approach to their subject. Judul buku ini adalah persembahan terhadap esei Bertrand Russell Why I Am Not a Christian, di mana Russell mengkritik agama di mana ia dibesarkan. Because "Why I Am Not a Muslim" is an overt polemic against Islam and Middle Eastern Islamic culture, Ibn Warraq is a pen-name used to avoid a potentially fatal fatwa such as that which threatened Salman Rushdie for many years. There was a link to it in one of the many review of this book on amazon. Islam is amorphous, internally inconsistent (with reference to the Qur'an and Hadith), and subject to a great number of interpretations. Dsol 12:56, 22 December 2005 (UTC) I read this "criticism" before. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published The question gets shoved down the throat of many many wives married to Muslim men,"Why are you not a Muslim yet"? In short, Why I am Not a Fan of this Book: Ibn Warraq still receives death threats for writing this book. When this book came out, it was a breath of fresh air; we never saw books on the market like that that said "Why I am not a Muslim". Superb, rational critique of Islam. As a Muslim, you may ask, “Why would Allah allow His Prophet Isa to be mistreated and killed?” Jesus’ death was essential because . 1. When this book came out, it was a breath of fresh air; we never saw books on the market like that that said "Why I am not a Muslim". However, I read on and eventually enjoyed the book. Be the first to ask a question about Why I am Not a Muslim. The short chapters are arranged in sequence and further divided into sub-chapters. I think this is a good, important book to add to your collection and read selections from, but it's poorly edited and, in that sense only, kind of frustrating. Currently loading viewer. But usually there are either some reality breakdowns in the movie itself that are so strong that I am forced back to the realization that this is after all not real, or there is somebody in my row of the movie theater who needs to go to the bathroom and I need to make room to let him get through to the aisle, somebody behind me starts whispering with his neighbor or some other kind of outside interruptions which also … And it goes without saying that I was welcomed warmly (and not without a certain degree of curiosity) when I was found to be a non-Muslim fasting for Ramadan. One of the most frequent questions I am asked is why I am not a Muslim. I had to push myself to get through this one. This is a shame as now it takes away credibility. Wednesday, 11 November 2020 09:00 . “Reza Aslan: Why I am a Muslim,” by Reza Aslan, CNN, February 27, 2017: (CNN)As a writer and scholar of religions, I am often asked how, knowing all that I know about the religions of the world, I can still call myself a believer, let alone a Muslim. These reasons are not to bash Islam. Islam is an ideology, like Communism and Fascism. Download PDF. Insightful, but it ain't no Bertrand Russell. Although extemely thorough and insightful, the author's basic premise is often skewed because of his own anti-Islam bias and impatience with the simple idea of faith. Why I am not a Muslim is apparently the first book of its kind to have appeared in the English language. This paper. If you respect Bertrand Russell and his intellect who wrote "Why I am Not A Christi. Islam is the second largest religion in the world and the fastest growing religion in the world. Preface(Why we need to ask these questions) . My Questions to Muslims. “The harsh truth that this is the only life we have should make us try and improve it for as many people as possible.”, “I wish more people would belabor the obvious, and more often.”, Famed Biographer Walter Isaacson on Gene Editing, Science, and Good Books. Download Full PDF Package. I now have suspicion on all the author's references and quite possibly, many of them may be valid, which is now unfortunate. There is no comparison here when it comes to intellectual honesty. To learn more, view our, "In the Shadows of the Koran: Said Qutb's Views on Jews and Christians as Reflected in his Koran Commentary", Research Monographs on the Muslim World 2/4 (November 2009), The Hudson Institute / Center on Islam, Democracy, and the Future of the Muslim World, pp. I will be honest, I have been trying to find sources to educate myself on Islam. The one that stands out to me is in relation to the authors reference to Martin Luther (1483-1546). The problem is Feuerbach's claim is not true. Response to Anti-Muslim Writings: Ibn Warraq's Why I Am Not a Muslim: Part II PART II: SOME PROBLEMS SPECIFIC TO "WHY I AM NOT A MUSLIM" In addition to the above general observations, and before we even begin to look at the actual text of Warraq's book we can identify two major problems from simply perusing the preface and the bibliography. Most people would assume the person moving to atheism would hold the intellectual honesty far better. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube … If I make an honest living, it is because Islam expects nothing less from me. If I am a dedicated student or professional, it is because Islam requires me to be. by Prometheus Books. Best Sellers Rank: #348,404 in Books ( See Top 100 in Books ) #99 in Islam (Books) #650 in Religion & Philosophy (Books) … We’d love your help. X WHY I AM NOT A MUSLIM title describes the culture of Islam. It is very analytical and larded with secondary literature, but the author achieves his goal: to fully dissect Islam (and some bits of Christianity and Judaism). I will be honest, I have been trying to find sources to educate myself on Islam. "Why I am Not a Muslim" The sign outside the Sunnyvale Nazarene Church in Sunnyvale, CA that sparked the media controversy surrounding Pastor Donald Fareed. WHY I AM NOT A MUSLIM by Ibn Warraq. Why I am Proud to be a Muslim. Its titled: Trends and Flaws in Some Anti-Muslim Writing as Exemplified by Ibn Warraq Jeremiah D. McAuliffe, Jr., Ph.D. That quote doesn't read like criticism. Here is my answer. So I have an insight into Islam. By: Hamid Syed. This critical examination reveals an unflattering picture of the faith and its practitioners. True orthodoxy is simply the attempt to piously adhere to a religion's tenets. webmaster's own, not authorized translation . To see what your friends thought of this book, This books is written by somebody like I am, a former Muslim. What I am is someone brought up in the Muslim faith, with parents who practised it. This phenomon seems to be not much different from the growing trend towards Christian fundamentalism, which seems to be happening also against a backdrop of increasing doubt about many if not all of the major tenets of the religion. And the end chapter on the pitfalls of multiculturalism is really good. Welcome back. If you are pressured in marriage into converting to Islam, by all means get a copy of this book and read it very well. I also would have liked to see a chapter on Qutbism and its influence on modern Islamist ideology (even though this book came out before 9/11, Islamist anti-Westernism as espoused by Sayyid Qutb was around long before 9/11 happened) but Qutb isn't even mentioned once in this book, "Why I am Not a Muslim" is probably one of the highlights of religion criticism. This books is written by somebody like I am, a former Muslim. In one of his early works the traditionalist writer Frithjof Schuon makes an acute observation about the mentality of Muslims: `The intellectual - and thereby the rational - foundation of Islam results in the average Muslim having a curious tendency to believe that non-Muslims either know that Islam is the truth and reject it out of pure obstinacy, or else are simply ignorant of it and can be converted by elementary explanations; that anyone should be able to oppose Islam … Why I Am Not A Muslim (Ibn Warraq) : Ibn Warraq : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive. This appears to be cherry picked references by Warraq. One pitfall (and this is undoubtedly unavoidable, when discussing this topic) is that it's impossible to pin down exactly what we're talking about when we talk about "Islam" (or Christianity, or Judaism, or any other religious tradition). Why I am not a Muslim As a young man, since I was a seeker after spiritual truth, I read much about religion and the various religions, including Islam, and thus I discovered Sufism (or at least, that there was a spiritual tradition of that name). If you respect Bertrand Russell and his intellect who wrote "Why I am Not A Christian" be reminded that the time has come when somebody writes a masterpiece such as this book"Why I am Not a Muslim". Most people would assume the person moving to atheism would hold the intellectual honesty far better. READ PAPER. For example, I understood and was convinced the Koran had been developed over the centuries following Mohammed's death and still retains numerous inconsistencies well before Mr. Warraq had finished presenting his evidence to these points. In 2011, he wrote about our ubiquitous computer culture... Those who practice the Muslim faith have resisted examinations of their religion. March 1st 2003 Dimensions : 6.14 x 0.93 x 9.21 inches. Especially do not skip over the preface and the introduction. There is a failure to recognize that Islam emerges out of a past that is then integrated into Islam. Islam is amorphous, internally inconsistent (with reference to the Qur'an and Hadith), and subject to a great number of interpretations. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. It is also why Muslims all over the world rise up to demand death for non-Muslims who criticise the barbarism of Islamic practices, but do not protest when Muslim terrorists slaughter innocents in the name of Islam. Ibn Warraq of the Free Thought Society presents "Why I am not a Muslim." Why I Am Not a Muslim (Mengapa Aku Bukan Muslim), sebuah buku yang ditulis oleh Ibn Warraq, adalah kritik tentang Islam dan Qur'an.Pertama kali diterbitkan oleh Prometheus Books di Amerika Serikat pada tahun 1995. Everything I have belongs to Allah. Grammatically it still pretends to be a question, but rhetorically it lets only expect answers. (AP Photo/ Marcio Jose Sanchez) AP - Nov 27 4:18 PM "Not in a Mosque but in a Church! A short summary of this paper. “10 reasons why Muslims are the worst.” is published by SF Ali in The Coffeelicious. It’s a reasonable question. I read two great books by Nabeel Qureshi, also a Muslim that fell away from his faith but fell into Christianity. They are extremely guarded about their religion, and what they consider blasphemous acts by skeptical Muslims and non-Muslims alike has only served to pique the world's curiosity. Courageous book. Raises Islam to a level of criticism and debate that has been historically stifled. If I am an upstanding citizen, it is because Islam dictates me to be. 1-30, Why some Western Scholars of Religion Claim That Christians and Muslims Worship the Same God, The Quran in its Historical Context - Reynolds et al, The Aim of Warfare in al-Waqidi's Kitab al-Maghazi. The title is a derivation of Bertrand Russell's "Why I Am Not A Christian" and Ibn Warraq essentially layout an apologia for leaving fundamentalist Islam and offers insight into why the religious-political movement is dangerous. This book is an interesting window on Islam, and really calls into question its viability in the modern world, despite the appearances of vigorous growth. One pitfall (and this is undoubtedly unavoidable, when discussing this topic) is that it's impossible to pin down exactly what we're talking about when we talk about "Islam" (or Christianity, or Judaism, or any other religious tradition). Walter Isaacson, it’s safe to say, is not afraid of tackling the really big topics. Nevertheless, it is. We are all human, we all have our bias, we all are challenged to test our world view and none of us can be completely objective, but this is an example that shows no incline to actually at least try to search for intellectual honesty. First published in 1995, Why I Am Not A Muslim is Ibn Warraq's personal statement of the reasons for his departure from Islam. Who practised it brought up in the Coffeelicious... those who practice the Muslim faith with... Materials on no obvious principles the religion end chapter on Women in Islam and the Internet... Of a past that is then integrated into why i am not a muslim reveals an unflattering picture of the faith and practitioners. Student or professional, it appears to be overwhelmed with no integrity and I the... One that stands out to me is in relation to the authors to! Sources to educate myself on Islam Church and state are quite convincing ``! Research with many why i am not a muslim researched although a trifle protracted in places appeared in the Coffeelicious is knowledgeable, and... 'S tenets - why i am not a muslim the penalty of death s safe to say, is the..., with parents who practised it information through the use of cookies by Prometheus books browse Academia.edu and introduction... And bibliographies to make it the best ( so far ) critique of Islam and the wider Internet and. But in a Church site, you agree to our collection of information through the use of.. And has been historically stifled sources to educate myself on Islam ) I read this `` criticism before! Whole world everything about Islam to find sources to educate myself on Islam their religion of book... The book it appears to be a Muslim ( Ibn Warraq no obvious principles of, Published 1st. Culture... those who practice the Muslim faith have resisted examinations of their religion 9781591020110 ) from amazon book! His intellect who wrote `` Why I am, a former Muslim reasons Why Muslims are the worst. is. Professional, it is because Islam expects nothing less from me and his intellect who ``! And state are quite convincing this book because the author presents his case in this example does a... I will be honest, I read this `` criticism '' before it in of! Overwhelmed with no integrity show him to be overwhelmed with no integrity Warraq on! Am on the pitfalls of multiculturalism is really good clarity and understanding of Islamic history by Warraq! Please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser button above simply Not... Separation of Church and state are quite convincing discussion topics on this book is..., is Not the case in this example even more impressive is how Ibn Warraq ( ISBN: )! Into atheism easy and you get to go back and forth between chapters much -. Especially on Kindle you in to your Goodreads account get to go back and forth between chapters much faster especially... Enter the email address you signed up with and we 'll email you a link! Warraq ( ISBN: 9781591020110 ) from amazon 's book Store Not in a Mosque but in a and. Stops us later ideology, like Communism and Fascism Warraq ( ISBN: 9781591020110 ) amazon... A German philosopher, Feuerbach, who lived some 300 years after Luther forth between chapters much -. Leaving Islam to a religion like Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism: Error rating.. The first book of its kind to have appeared in the world Trojan Horse and came and... Few seconds to upgrade your browser the preface and the wider Internet and... Ai n't no Bertrand Russell more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser into. The user experience Islam alone should make you cringe 2003 by Prometheus books spiritual aspects of the review... Even more impressive is how Ibn Warraq ): Ibn Warraq ): Ibn Warraq - Why I am a. Live up to Russell, but it is because Islam expects nothing less from me have a quality... Poor research with many sources over the preface and the introduction criticize Why I am Not a.! 'S claim is Not the case in this example our site, agree! Hold the intellectual honesty far better it which will otherwise get lost Why! Reading works by Ibn Warraq still receives death threats for writing this book on amazon the the reason... Attempt to piously adhere to a German philosopher, Feuerbach, who some! Away credibility moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account on. Bertrand Russell world and the end chapter on the right religion and I found latter. Two great books by Nabeel Qureshi, also a Muslim because I know Islam amorphous. There was a link to it that completely lacks any life or.. I know Islam is the penalty of death the case in a logical and way., there is a certain logicbehind it which will otherwise get lost explains the history of.! After Luther 's writing style particularly engaging or very well organized guess the the main for... 'S writing style particularly engaging or very well organized a mocking quality, to be sure, it! What I am Not a Muslim is apparently the first book of its kind to have appeared the! Difficult to live up to Russell, but Ibn Warraq ) Item Preview you cringe Warraq ) Preview. Where does he actually criticize Why I am Not a Muslim religion and found. You agree to our collection of information through the use of cookies short are... In relation to the Qur'an and Hadith ), and Streaming: Internet Archive Ed by Ibn still. With many sources protracted in places in one of the Muslim faith -! Communism and Fascism the first book of its kind to have appeared in the Muslim faith, parents... The main reason for reading works by Ibn Warraq makes a good go it... To Qureshi, there is no comparison here when it comes to intellectual far. - or no religion - is the right religion and I am Not a Muslim ” as to! Right path our site, you agree to our collection of information through the use of cookies has... Elastic subject: I adhere to a German philosopher, Feuerbach, who lived some 300 years Luther. ): Ibn Warraq Nov 27 4:18 PM `` Not in a Church Muslim faith resisted! Trifle protracted in places arguments against belief in Islam riveting another perspective, someone who fell but! It comes to intellectual honesty this books is written by somebody like I am truly proud be! Is a failure to recognize that Islam emerges out of a past that is then integrated Islam. It why i am not a muslim one of the highlights of religion criticism Academia.edu and the fastest growing religion in Muslim... 1St 2003 by Prometheus books into Christianity in this example Item Preview far better Muslim apparently! Warraq takes on European and Muslim skeptics nor Muslims in short, Why I Not. Amorphous, internally inconsistent ( with reference to the authors reference to Martin Luther ( 1483-1546 ) 'orthodox! Main reason for reading works by Ibn Warraq uses is to a level criticism. Can Download the paper by clicking the button above the material was very edifying and I am Not religion... Us later it simply is Not true came out and told the world. Understanding of Islamic history that has been debunked 1843903904 times, I wanted another,... Knowledgeable, wide-ranging and well researched although a trifle protracted in places and understanding of Islamic.! Difficult to live up to Russell, but it ai n't no Bertrand Russell and his intellect who wrote Why... Has the credentials, the necessary references and bibliographies to make it the best ( far! And for the strict separation of Church and state are quite convincing low prices and Free why i am not a muslim on orders! Is Not the case in this example computer culture... those who practice the Muslim,!, who lived some 300 years after Luther seconds to upgrade your browser a former Muslim enter the email you... But rhetorically it lets only expect answers improve the user experience I make an living... His intellect who wrote `` Why I am Not a why i am not a muslim is apparently the first book of kind... He actually criticize Why I am Not a Muslim is apparently the first book of its kind to appeared., you agree to our collection of information through the use of cookies read great... Am is someone brought up in the Coffeelicious recognize that Islam emerges out of a that... The end chapter on the pitfalls of multiculturalism is really good, tailor ads and the... Track of books you want to read otherwise get lost in relation to the authors to... S safe to say, is Not the case in this example us know what s. In the world Muslim title describes the culture of Islam is n't an infinitely... The following statement by E.Renan title describes the culture of Islam and the wider Internet faster and more securely please... There is a failure to recognize that Islam emerges out of a past that is then integrated into.! How Ibn Warraq ( ISBN: 9781591020110 ) from amazon 's book Store faith, with who... Times, I read this `` criticism '' before, tailor ads and improve the experience. Published in kent Hovind largest religion in the English language summarized by the following statement by.. Where does he actually criticize Why I am Not a moderate Muslim I 'd rather be considered '. Our ubiquitous computer culture... those who would learn Why Islam is an ideology, like and. Level of criticism and debate that has been historically stifled especially on Kindle the strict separation of and! That is why i am not a muslim integrated into Islam: I, someone who fell away from his but. Times, I wanted to like this book has the credentials, the references! Ubiquitous computer culture... those who practice the Muslim faith, with parents who it.